
How can an owner compare delay risk across substation upgrades?
Owners compare delay risk across substation upgrades by forecasting how likely each upgrade's work is to be ready for its booked outage and what missing that outage would cost.
The short version: If you’re running several substation upgrades at once, the most reliable way to rank them is by how likely each upgrade is to be ready for its booked outage, and how long the upgrade would wait for the next window if that outage were missed.
Key takeaways:
- On a live network, lost weeks only cost time once they push work past a booked outage, and until then they simply use up the upgrade’s margin
- Missing an outage can add months to an upgrade, because the next window the system operator can offer may be half a year away
- Forecasting each upgrade’s readiness from its own schedule lets an owner weight the chance of missing the outage against the cost of a miss
- Once that ranking exists, the owner can look for places where several upgrades depend on the same circuits or suppliers at the same time
Picture three substation upgrades in the same illustrative programme, each of which has lost four weeks at this month’s schedule update.
Two of the upgrades had enough margin before their booked outages to absorb the four weeks, so their finish dates stay where they were. On the third upgrade, the work now finishes two weeks after its transformer changeover outage begins, and the next window the system operator can offer opens 26 weeks later.
The same four-week delay therefore leaves two upgrades on track and adds 26 weeks to the third. Ranking these upgrades by weeks lost, or by a forecast finish date on its own, would treat all three as equally at risk, so an owner needs to know how likely each upgrade is to be ready for its outage and what missing that outage would cost.
How should an owner compare delay risk across substation upgrades?
The most useful comparison sets the likelihood that each upgrade will be ready for its booked outage against the delay a missed outage would cause. Owners can build this comparison from the schedules their project teams already keep by following five steps:
- Name the outage each upgrade depends on: Record the outage booked with the system operator, its dates, and the last date the booking can be changed without losing priority
- Define what “ready” means for each upgrade: List the work that has to be finished before the equipment can be taken out of service, and mark that work as a single milestone in the schedule
- Forecast the readiness milestone: Use the same forecasting method on every upgrade at every update, and compare the range of likely dates with the first day of the outage
- Work out what a missed outage would cost: Find out when the next outage could be granted, so that a miss can be expressed as weeks of delay to completion
- Rank the upgrades and look for overlaps: Order the upgrades by the likelihood and cost of a miss, then check whether any of them rely on the same resources in the weeks before their outages
The resulting order can look quite different from the delays each project reports, because an upgrade with plenty of margin can absorb a bad month that would cost another upgrade its window. That difference changes which upgrade needs the owner’s attention first. Insights Pro carries out step three using each team’s existing schedule and gives the readiness milestone a range of likely dates.
Why does the same delay mean different things on different upgrades?
Outages on a transmission network are planned many months ahead, because the system operator has to keep the whole network secure while parts of the network are switched off. If the work is ready before the outage starts, a delay uses up margin and the finish date holds. If the work isn’t ready, the upgrade has to wait for the next window, and the delay to completion becomes the gap between the two windows, however small the original delay was.
In Great Britain, the transmission owners build detailed plans a year ahead, and NESO’s network access planning team works through those plans with the generators and distribution network operators affected by each outage. NESO says around 2,500 outages typically go into its final year-ahead plan, which is issued in week 49, and that NESO then processes over 17,000 changes to that plan from transmission owners in a typical year. Any change after a transmission owner’s first submission means NESO has to start its detailed assessment of that outage again.
In the US, each regional transmission organisation sets its own deadlines, and PJM’s rules are a good example. PJM’s Manual 3 says outages longer than five days must be submitted before the first of the month, six months ahead, while outages longer than 30 days must be in before 1 February for the planning year that starts on 1 June, with whichever deadline is stricter applying. PJM puts outages submitted on time ahead of late ones, and where two on-time requests clash, the request submitted first takes priority.
What does “ready for the outage” mean?
Outage readiness is the point at which all the work that has to happen before the equipment comes out of service is complete. On a substation upgrade, that work might include:
- The new transformer or switchgear delivered, installed and tested
- Foundations and civils finished
- Protection and control systems ready to commission
- Enabling works, such as diversions, cleared
The owner defines readiness for each upgrade, because the work that must come first depends on how the connection is staged. Marking readiness as one milestone gives the forecast a specific date to aim at, and placing that milestone next to the booked outage shows how much margin the upgrade has left.

In the example, upgrade A has started the month with 8 weeks of margin, B with 6 and C with 2. After losing four weeks each, A has 4 weeks of margin left and B has 2, while C is two weeks short. C’s outage moves from week 26 to week 52, so a two-week delay to the work becomes 26 weeks of delay to completion. The example assumes A’s and B’s next windows are as far away as C’s, so the remaining margin decides their order.
B looks comfortable on paper, but two weeks leaves very little room, and a single forecast date would hide how close B is to missing its window. For that reason, the forecast should give a range for each readiness date, and the measure to rank on is the likelihood of being ready before the outage starts.
What drives readiness on a substation upgrade?
Readiness usually depends on two very different kinds of work: large equipment with long lead times, and small enabling jobs that are very easy to overlook.
Large equipment: Transformer lead times have grown sharply in recent years, and Wood Mackenzie reported in April 2024 that average lead times had risen from around 50 weeks in 2021 to 120 weeks in 2024, with large substation power transformers taking 80 to 210 weeks. In August 2025, Wood Mackenzie estimated a 30% shortfall in US power transformer supply for that year, although neither source gives a separate figure for Great Britain. If the factory moves a transformer’s production slot, an upgrade can lose its outage before any work has started on site.
Small enabling works: Small enabling jobs are much easier to overlook than large equipment, because they rarely get the attention a transformer order does. At nPlan’s Summer AI Day 2026, Peter Hancock, Project Director of National Grid’s Didcot Substation, told us that early on our forecast flagged small activities that weren’t getting much attention but could still disrupt the schedule, such as minor utility diversions for water, small power and sewage. Didcot has to connect into a live network right next to the site, so a diversion that nobody is watching can still sit on the path to the outage.
Insights Pro forecasts every activity in the schedule, drawing on more than 780,000 past project schedules, so the activities behind the readiness milestone get their own forecast too. Driving Paths shows the critical path alongside the near-critical paths that could become sources of unexpected risk, and Mitigation Strategies lets the team test a mitigation against the forecast before anyone commits to the change.
What do several upgrades have in common?
Once each upgrade has a readiness forecast and a cost for missing its outage, the owner can look at what the upgrades share in the weeks before their outages.
- Outages that depend on each other: NESO often agrees one outage on condition that another has finished first, so check which upgrades sit on connected circuits before assuming both outages can happen at once
- Equipment from the same factory: Two upgrades waiting on transformers or switchgear from one supplier share that supplier’s delivery queue
- Specialist protection and commissioning staff: Where the same people move between sites, two upgrades that need them in the same weeks are competing for one resource
When two upgrades compete for the same resource, the upgrade higher up the ranking should usually get that resource first. In the example, suppose A and C both need the same commissioning team in weeks 22 to 26, and their current dates assume the team splits its time between them. Moving two weeks of the team’s time from A to C brings C’s readiness forward to week 26 and pushes A’s back to week 28 (illustrative assumptions). Because A’s outage is in week 30, both upgrades keep their outages and A’s spare margin pays for C’s recovery, although C is left with no margin at all, and one more bad week would delay C by 26 weeks.
The forecast shows which contractor or type of work drives each date, and the owner can check with contractors who is on which team. For owners running many upgrades, Portfolio forecasts every schedule the same way at each update and shows which projects are most likely to be delayed and why. Portfolio also groups similar risks across projects automatically and shows which projects each risk affects, which is how a PMO spots risks that several projects share.
How do the rules differ in Great Britain and the US?
Great Britain
Ofgem’s RIIO-3 Final Determination for electricity transmission, published on 4 December 2025 and covering 1 April 2026 to 31 March 2031, introduced a Major Projects delivery incentive. For upgrades that Ofgem places under the incentive, the penalty starts the day after the target delivery date, with no grace period. An approved Delay Event pushes the penalty date back, but only if the cause is on Ofgem’s fixed list, sits outside the transmission owner’s control and causes at least 30 days of delay. Supply chain problems aren’t on the list, so a late transformer leaves the penalty date unchanged.
The same determinations keep the Accelerated Strategic Transmission Investment (ASTI) rules in place for projects already under them. When Ofgem considers enforcement action over a late ASTI project, one factor Ofgem may look at is whether the project was late “as a direct result of the licensee prioritising resources on other ASTI projects to optimise its overall financial position inappropriately under the ASTI ODI in a manner that does not serve consumers’ interests”. Where an owner has several ASTI projects, a written ranking based on outage readiness shows why one project got the team or equipment ahead of the others.
The US
In the US, the evidence has to follow the regional transmission organisation’s rules, and PJM is a useful example again. PJM’s Manual 3 asks transmission owners to avoid outages longer than five days, with a restoration time over 72 hours, during the peak periods of 15 June to 15 September and 1 January to 28 February. PJM will deny some of these long outages, although PJM can make exceptions so that upgrades in its regional transmission expansion plan are installed on time. An outage rescheduled for any reason other than weather, or other than at PJM’s request, may lose its on-time status.
For each upgrade, a US comparison should therefore record the submission deadline that keeps the outage on time and the peak periods the outage needs to avoid, since a missed window could mean waiting until the peak period is over.
When is outage readiness the wrong measure?
Outage readiness is the wrong measure when an upgrade doesn’t need part of the live network switched off, such as a new substation on a separate site that only connects at the end, or an upgrade whose deadline is set by a planning consent or a connection agreement. For those upgrades, compare the forecast range for the completion date with whichever date actually binds, using the same checks an owner would use to test whether a contractor’s completion date is realistic. Where permanent power is the binding date, the milestones split the way they do for a data centre, into construction, first power and commissioning.
For upgrades that do depend on an outage, the three upgrades that each lost four weeks show the difference clearly. A report of weeks lost would rank A, B and C equally, whereas ranking by outage readiness puts C first and B second, because B is now only two weeks from losing its own window. The owner should work through the three upgrades in that order before the next submission deadline passes.
Frequently asked questions
Can nPlan forecast when the system operator will grant an outage?
nPlan doesn’t forecast outage approvals, because those decisions sit with NESO in Great Britain and with the regional transmission organisation in the US, as PJM’s decisions do for its members. We forecast the work in the owner’s schedule, including the readiness milestone before each outage, which shows how likely the work is to be ready and what is driving that likelihood, so the owner can decide whether to protect the outage or rebook the outage.
How often should an owner rerun the comparison?
Owners should rerun the comparison at every schedule update and always before the last date an outage change can be submitted. Under PJM’s Manual 3, for example, an outage longer than five days has to be submitted before the first of the month six months before the outage starts, so the ranking needs to be up to date well before then.
Can the comparison cover upgrades with schedules from different contractors?
The comparison can cover upgrades from different contractors, as long as each schedule has a status date and includes the readiness milestone the owner has defined. A schedule without a status date still produces dates, but those dates can’t be relied on, because the schedule can’t separate finished work from work still to do. Insights Pro reads schedules from Primavera P6, Asta Powerproject and Microsoft Project, so every upgrade can be forecast the same way, whichever tool its contractor uses.
Sources
- NESO, Network access planning: What happens when there's a request for an outage? (checked 10 November 2026)
- PJM, Manual 3: Transmission Operations, revision 71, effective 20 May 2026 (revision 72 redline, effective 18 November 2026, leaves section 4.2 unchanged)
- Ofgem, RIIO-3 Final Determinations: Electricity Transmission, 4 December 2025
- Ofgem, Decision to modify the special licence conditions in the electricity transmission licences: Accelerated Strategic Transmission Investment, August 2023
- Wood Mackenzie, Power transformers and distribution transformers will face supply deficits of 30% and 10% in 2025, 14 August 2025
- Wood Mackenzie, Supply shortages and an inflexible market give rise to high power transformer lead times, 2 April 2024
- nPlan, National Grid's Peter Hancock at nPlan Summer AI Day 2026: The Highlights, 6 August 2026
- nPlan Insights Pro: Driving Paths and Mitigation Strategies
- nPlan Portfolio
- nPlan, From AI-driven forecasting to rapid decision making: why we built Driving Paths
- nPlan, How can a PMO spot schedule risks shared by several projects or contractors?
- nPlan, How can a data-centre owner assess risk between construction, first power and commissioning?
- nPlan, How can an owner assess whether a contractor's completion date is realistic?
.jpg)
Loving every drop of AI-powered project intelligence: Part III - the final word from Anglian Water
In the third and final chapter of our blog series spotlighting nPlan CEO Dev Amratia’s revealing conversation with Euan Black, Head of Delivery Portfolio Management at Anglian Water, we move beyond implementation and transformation—and into tangible results, cultural shifts, and aspirations for the future.






